Cold calling guide

How to Run a Post-Promo Win-Loss Review for Your Dial Floor

A promo blitz just ended. Here's a simple win-loss review for books, shows, closes, and lost reasons by segment, so your next campaign starts smarter.

The promo is over. For two weeks your setters dialed hard, the closers ran a full calendar, and the leaderboard moved every afternoon. Now the floor is tired, the manager wants to start planning the next campaign, and the only number anyone remembers is total books.

That's the moment most teams waste. Total books tells you the promo happened. It doesn't tell you which lists worked, which offers pulled sits that actually showed, why quotes were lost, or which setters booked appointments that closers could close. Without that, the next promo is a copy of the last one with a new date on it.

A post-promo win-loss review fixes that. It takes about an hour, uses data you already logged during the blitz, and gives you three or four specific changes for the next campaign. This post walks through how to run one on a home-services dial floor, whether you sell roofing, HVAC, solar, windows, bath remodels, or pest plans.

If you haven't run the blitz yet, start with how to run a two-week dial blitz. This post picks up the day after it ends.


Why a win-loss review beats a "how did it go?" meeting

The usual post-promo meeting is a round of opinions. The top setter says the list was great. The closer says half the sits were tire-kickers. The owner says the offer was too generous. Everyone is partly right, and nothing changes.

A win-loss review replaces opinions with a few fixed questions answered from the call log:

  • Where did books come from? Which list, zip, source, or campaign tag.
  • Which books turned into shows? And which segments had the worst no-show rate.
  • Which shows turned into closes? By setter, by closer, and by offer.
  • Why did we lose the rest? Using logged lost reasons, not memory.
  • What's still open? Quotes and callbacks that are still warm and need a dated next step.

If you logged consistent outcomes during the promo, you can answer every one of those in under an hour. If you didn't, the review will show you exactly which fields to fix before the next one.


Step 1: Freeze the promo window and tag

Before you look at anything, define what counts as "the promo."

  • Pick exact start and end dates. Include the confirmation days after the last booking day, since shows and closes trail books.
  • Filter to one campaign tag. If storm leads, inbound calls, and the promo list all ran at once, mixing them will hide what the promo actually did. The post on keeping storm and promo lists separate explains why separate tags matter.
  • Export or snapshot the data. Late edits keep trickling in for a week. A frozen snapshot means everyone in the review is looking at the same numbers.

Step 2: Build the funnel by segment

You need five counts for each segment: dials, conversations, books, shows, and closes. Segments are whatever you'd change next time:

  • List or lead source (old customers, purchased list, web leads, door-knock follow-ups)
  • Zip code or neighbourhood
  • Offer or promo variant
  • Setter
  • Closer

Keep it simple. A short written summary per segment works fine:

  • Past customers: 640 dials, 210 conversations, 48 books, 41 shows, 19 closes.
  • Purchased list, east zips: 2,300 dials, 310 conversations, 52 books, 29 shows, 8 closes.

Those two lines already tell a story. The purchased list produced more books, but the past-customer list produced more than twice the closes on a quarter of the dials. Next promo, past customers get worked first and harder.

Look at ratios, not raw totals:

  • Conversation rate shows list quality and calling times.
  • Book rate per conversation shows script and offer fit.
  • Show rate per book shows confirmation discipline and lead quality.
  • Close rate per show shows sit quality and closer performance.

A segment that books well and shows badly is usually a confirmation problem or a "free inspection" offer pulling people who aren't buying. A segment that shows well and closes badly is usually the wrong audience for the price point.


Step 3: Read the lost reasons

This is the part most teams skip, and it's the most useful.

Every lost show and every dead quote should have a short, consistent lost reason. Something like:

  • Price or financing
  • Went with competitor
  • Not the decision maker
  • Timing (wants spring, waiting on insurance, moving)
  • Didn't need it after inspection
  • No response after quote

Count them by segment. Patterns show up fast. If "not the decision maker" is a third of lost sits from one setter, that setter needs to confirm both homeowners will be present. If "timing" dominates, those aren't losses yet. They're future callbacks.

If your lost reasons are mostly blank or "other," that's your first fix. The post on using outcome tags for weekly coaching covers how to keep a short tag list that reps actually use under dial pace.


Step 4: Separate setter quality from closer quality

Promo leaderboards reward books. A win-loss review should check whether those books were worth having.

For each setter, look at:

  • Books per conversation
  • Show rate on their books
  • Close rate on their shown books, across closers

For each closer, look at close rate per show, split by which setter booked it.

You're looking for two things. First, setters with high book counts and weak show or close rates. They may be over-selling the appointment or skipping qualifying questions. Second, closers whose close rate drops sharply on one setter's books. That's a handoff problem, not a talent problem.

Keep this conversation about patterns, not blame. The goal is to fix the next promo's script and handoff notes, not to win an argument. For fair crediting rules, see how to attribute books vs closes fairly.


Step 5: Rescue what's still warm

Every promo leaves money on the table: quotes waiting on a spouse, homeowners who said "after the holidays," inspections that found work but haven't been priced.

Before the review ends, pull every open item from the promo and make sure each one has:

  • An owner. One person, not "the team."
  • A dated next step. A real callback date, not "follow up."
  • A short note. What was quoted, what the objection was, who decides.

Anything with no date gets one before anyone leaves the room. Anything that's truly dead gets a lost reason and comes off the active list. This one step often recovers more revenue than the next promo's first week.


Step 6: Write down three changes

End with a short written list. Three or four changes, each tied to something the data showed:

  1. Work past customers first in week one, before purchased lists.
  2. Add a second confirmation call for free-inspection books, which had the worst show rate.
  3. Require "both decision makers present?" as a logged field before booking.
  4. Drop the two zips with the lowest conversation rate, or test a different calling time there.

Save the list where the next promo plan will see it. A win-loss review that lives in one manager's head isn't worth much by spring.


A one-hour agenda you can reuse

  • 0 to 10 minutes: Confirm the promo window, tag, and snapshot.
  • 10 to 25 minutes: Funnel by segment. Note the best and worst two.
  • 25 to 40 minutes: Lost reasons by segment and setter.
  • 40 to 50 minutes: Open quotes and callbacks. Assign owners and dates.
  • 50 to 60 minutes: Agree on three changes and write them down.

Run it within a week of the promo ending, while people still remember the context behind the numbers.


What you need logged for this to work

You don't need a heavy CRM. You need a few fields filled in consistently on every call:

  • Campaign or list tag
  • Outcome (no answer, conversation, booked, not interested, callback)
  • Booked by and closed by
  • Show or no-show
  • Lost reason
  • Next due date for anything still open

If you're on a spreadsheet, the free call log template has these columns already. It works for a small floor and a single promo. Once several setters are editing the same sheet during a busy blitz, filters break and dues get missed, and the review gets harder to trust.

Dialed Sales is a cold-call tracker built for high-activity teams in roofing, solar, HVAC, and other home services. Setters log one-tap outcomes, every callback gets a dated due, and boards show books, shows, and dues cleared alongside dials. Sara AI can recap a campaign week and point out which open quotes are going stale, so the rescue step in your review is already half done.

If your last promo ended with a total and a shrug, grab the free call log template or start a free trial at dialedsales.com and set up your next campaign so the win-loss review almost writes itself.

Put every call on rails

Log a call in seconds, get follow-ups surfaced the day they're due, and keep a live leaderboard.